
Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing in North Idaho
The first question people ask after we hand them an estimate is almost always the same: should this be metal? Here is the honest comparison for a roof in Coeur d'Alene, Post Falls, Hayden or anywhere else in the Inland Northwest.
How each one handles our climate
Asphalt shingles handle snow, rain and sun well. Architectural shingles rated for this region last 25 to 30 years in practice, though sun exposure on a south-facing slope shortens that. Their weakness is ice damming along the eaves and granule loss from UV, both of which are manageable with proper ice and water shield and ventilation.
Metal sheds snow rather than holding it, which is a genuine advantage on a steep roof in a heavy snow year. Metal also resists moss, does not lose granules, and reflects summer heat. Its weakness is that it expands and contracts with temperature, which makes fastener and flashing detail far less forgiving of sloppy work. A poorly installed metal roof will fail at the screws and washers long before the panels wear out.
Lifespan and cost over time
An architectural asphalt roof costs roughly half what a standing seam metal roof costs on the same house and lasts about 25 to 30 years. A quality metal roof should go 45 to 50 years, and often longer. If you plan to stay in the house for decades, metal can be the cheaper roof over its life. If you may sell in ten years, the asphalt roof is almost always the better financial decision, because a buyer pays for a newer roof but not usually for the difference in material.
For current installed pricing on either, see roof replacement.
What each one does to your house
Asphalt suits the housing stock here: most homes in Spokane Valley and North Idaho are built for the look of a dimensional shingle roof, and a shingle roof reads as normal to a buyer or an appraiser.
Metal makes a statement. On a cabin, a barn-style house or a modern build it looks deliberate and excellent. On a 1970s split-level in a subdivision of identical split-levels, it looks like a decision somebody has to love, and it can complicate a sale. It is also noisier in rain and hail unless the roof has solid sheathing and proper underlayment, which any good installation includes anyway.
A note on snow shedding
Metal sheds snow, which sounds ideal until the snow lands on the walkway, the gas meter or the shrubs you planted under the drip line. A metal roof on a low slope also needs snow guards above doorways and driveways. That is an added cost people rarely budget for.
Maintenance
Asphalt needs very little: keep the gutters clear, treat moss if it appears, and have it inspected every few years. Metal needs a periodic check of fasteners and sealant, particularly on exposed fastener panels, and touch-up paint where a panel has been scratched. Neither is maintenance-free, and anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something.
Our recommendation for most homes here
For most homeowners in Spokane Valley, Spokane, Coeur d'Alene and Post Falls, a well-installed architectural shingle roof with ice and water shield at the eaves and a proper ridge vent is the best value on the market. Put the savings toward ventilation, better flashing and a longer workmanship warranty rather than toward a metal roof on a house that does not need one.
Choose metal when the roof is steep and sheds snow badly, when you plan to stay 20 years or more, when the architecture calls for it, or when the roof is visible from the street on a house where a metal roof fits the design.
Either way, the installation matters more than the material
A premium shingle installed badly fails in eight years. A mid-grade shingle installed correctly lasts its full rated life. That is why our estimates itemize the underlayment, the flashing and the ventilation rather than just naming a shingle brand. If you would like to see what we put on a roof and why, call (509) 404-4444 or request an estimate.
Want a roofer to look at it in person?
ALPHA LLC inspects roofs across Spokane Valley, Spokane and North Idaho. The inspection and the written estimate are free.
